Try the political quiz

55 Replies

 @ISIDEWITHasked…2mos2MO

Would you support your country's military using ground robots in battle, and why or why not?

 @9KWQG2R from Minnesota commented…2mos2MO

 @9KWPHM6 from Virginia commented…2mos2MO

 @9KWPGKS from North Carolina commented…2mos2MO

 @9KWP9C9Republican from Pennsylvania commented…2mos2MO

 @ISIDEWITHasked…2mos2MO

Do you think the use of ground robots in combat makes war more or less ethical?

 @9KWSJD7 from Pennsylvania commented…2mos2MO

More ethical. The less human lives lost fighting a rich man’s war, the better.

 @9KWRT94commented…2mos2MO

 @ISIDEWITHasked…2mos2MO

If robots are doing the fighting, what emotions does that provoke when considering the value of human life versus robot 'life'?

 @9KWPNF5commented…2mos2MO

I feel as if its a good point but robots can only be programmed, humans can be reprogrammed to be trained assassins/killers and legally for their country.

 @9KWPDJM from Illinois commented…2mos2MO

 @9KWTJCGJustice party member from Pennsylvania commented…2mos2MO

Robots have no morality, and that takes away from military training. It is unhealthy and provokes the usage of robots in our every day lives.

 @UncommonLocustGreenfrom New Jersey disagreed…2mos2MO

This is a key piece of the emerging dystopian future where human error and false assumptions are written in code and executed at lightning speed without any human governance. The idea that entire populations could be held hostage to machines controlled by a few is the logical end point of this technology.

Be afraid.

 @RobustUnanimousSocialistfrom North Carolina agreed…2mos2MO

Of course killer robots are the perfect solution to disloyal working class soldiers who might decide to disobey orders and not shoot their families and friends.

 @FreeTradeJellyfishNo Labelsfrom Maine commented…2mos2MO

The next step is when independent AI weapons have to decide whether to take out the enemy's independent AI weapons. Eventually there may be no humans on battlefields. There would be a lot of destruction, but no loss of human life. But if countries are just destroying each other's robots, why not use virtual robots instead of real ones. Will war become a giant video game but with real results?

 @SolidSquirrelSocialist from Arkansas agreed…2mos2MO

How many young American men and women died or were permanently disabled because we didn't mount weapons on drone platforms in Afghanistan and Iraq. Today there is no reason an American soldier should walk openly in a hostile environment. AI should be reserved for defensive purposes.

 @MotivatedRedStatePeace and Freedomfrom Texas commented…2mos2MO

There is no point in creating killing machines to kill other machines. These tools are going to be used to control civilians. These tools, combined with the rise of authoritarian governments, should give people a reason to be concerned and demand a resolution regarding the use of autonomous or drone warfare against civilians. Ideally the resolution should be passed before they are used, unlike the resolutions against chemical and nuclear warfare, which were only passed due to widespread horror and condemnation.

 @M0derateRaisinsNo Labelsfrom Texas agreed…2mos2MO

We seem dead set on getting to a point where we can treat war as one giant real world video game. The more technology progresses the happier I am that I’m old and will be long gone before most if this comes to fruition.

Engagement

The historical activity of users engaging with this general discussion.

Loading data...

Loading chart... 

Demographics

Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion

Loading data...